Best Insurance Digital Marketing Agencies (2026) – Ranked by Case Studies
First Family Insurance Client-verified
Social Media Ads, PPC, SEO
Insurance
11-50 Employees
N/A
Coral Springs, FL
N/A- 1,000+ leads per month after a year, at a 30% landing page conversion rate
- 80% contact rate
- Average cost per lead of $12, down from $26 in the first months
The Agency Insurance Group Client-verified
Lead Generation, Email MarketingInsuranceN/AN/ABoerne, TXN/A- 10x+ ROI on the engagement
- 30%+ LinkedIn connection rate and 10+ new appointments
- 6-figure deal closed within 90 days
Lead Generation, SEO, Email MarketingInsurance11-50 EmployeesN/AWest Bloomfield, MIN/A- 1,400+ prospects generated in 60 days
- Ranking for 177 keywords, up 132 in 60 days
- 347 LinkedIn conversations started in under 60 days
Insureflow Client-verified
Lead Generation, Email MarketingInsurance11-50 EmployeesN/ALondon, United KingdomN/A- 100+ leads in under three months
- Near 3% success rate from a data set of ~6,000 contacts
Coface Client-verified
Lead Generation, Email MarketingInsurance1K-5K EmployeesN/ABois-Colombes, FranceN/A- 1,200 high-quality leads generated through Sopro campaigns
Fetch Pet Insurance Client-verified
PPC, Social Media Ads, SEOInsurance201-500 EmployeesN/ANew York, NYN/A- 56% increase in new policy sales
- 400% increase in paid social sales
- 42% decrease in cost per sale
- 64% decrease in cost per sale for non-brand paid search
Perr&Knight Client-verified
Web Design, Web Development, SEOInsurance51-200 EmployeesN/ABoca Raton, FLN/A- 168% increase in contact form submissions
- 193% increase in consultation requests on the website
- 84% Growth in organic search traffic
- 125% increase in sessions
- 150% increase in rise in direct traffic
UniTrust Insurance Brokers Client-verified
SEO, PPC, Web DesignInsurance51-200 EmployeesN/ADubai, United Arab EmiratesN/A- 400% lead generation
- 500K+ brand reach
- Top 5 search rankings
Squaremouth Client-verified
GEO, SEO, Content MarketingInsurance11-50 EmployeesN/ASt. Petersburg, FLN/A- 270% more revenue from ChatGPT in 6 months
- Search traffic up 78% while competitors lost 34.5% to AI Overviews
Web Design, UX Recommendations, Data & AnalyticsInsurance10K+ EmployeesN/ABasel, SwitzerlandN/A- 925+ unique users per week (Jan. 2019)
- 160+ daily visits to the customer portal (Jan. 2019)
- 1.2 services used by each visitor on average (Jan. 2019)
Customer Data Platform, Personalization, Data & AnalyticsInsurance1K-5K EmployeesN/ASingaporeN/A- 40% reduction in CPA
- 92% increase in click-through rate
- 452% increase in online revenue year over year
- Car insurance early online renewal: 44% (2021/22) to 72% (2022/23)
- Motorcycle insurance early online renewal: 52% (2021/22) to 68% (2022/23)
Web Design, UX Recommendations, BrandingInsurance10K+ EmployeesN/AZurich, SwitzerlandN/A- 253% increased conversions
- 265% more articles read (unique visitors)
- 800% more product views (page views)
Content Marketing, PPC, Email MarketingInsurance11-50 EmployeesN/ASt. Petersburg, FLN/A- 59 blog posts produced
- 4850% increase in referring domains
- 5x increase in organic traffic
Link Building, SEO, Content MarketingInsurance10K+ EmployeesN/AWhite Plains, NYN/A- 22 new backlinks acquired in one month
- 4500 backlinks acquired in one month
- 200 new referring domains in one month
Web Design, Web Development, SEOInsurance1-10 EmployeesN/ANew York, NYN/A- Users can find information in 7 clicks vs the 10-click goal
Email Marketing, Content MarketingInsurance10K+ EmployeesN/ANew York, NYN/A- Visits to the agent portal +620%
- Email open rates above 50%
- ~9 million consumer impressions through agents
PPC, Email MarketingInsurance10K+ EmployeesN/AToronto, CanadaN/A- Website visits +73%
- Display ad CTR 500% above industry average
- Benefits sales ~30% over annual goals
Email Marketing, Content MarketingInsurance10K+ EmployeesN/ANew York, NYN/A- 74% likely to open another email
- 67% more likely to quote Travelers auto policies
- 66% said it changed how they think about Travelers
- Six-episode animated email series
Content Marketing, SEO, Web DesignInsurance1-10 EmployeesN/AReno, NVN/A- $123K Average Monthly Organic Traffic Value
- 544 Links Earned to Date
- 60% Increase in Monthly Organic Traffic
Content Marketing, Link BuildingInsurance51-200 EmployeesN/ASan Francisco, CAN/A- Page One Ranking for "Startup Insurance"
- 24,000% Increase in Organic Traffic to the Blog
- 460% Increase in Links
Content Marketing, Link BuildingInsurance201-500 EmployeesN/AAustin, TXN/A- 1,580+ Links Earned to Resources
- $7.7M+ Increase in Traffic Value
- 354% Increase in Organic Traffic
PPC, Lead GenerationInsurance5K-10K EmployeesN/AStockholm, SwedenN/A- 70% increase in leads
- -5% decrease in cost per acquisition
- 60% increased click through rates
Link Building, Content MarketingInsurance11-50 EmployeesN/AReno, NVN/A- 159% Increase in YoY Referral Traffic
- 104% Increase in YoY Organic Traffic
- 118 Earned Backlinks
SEO, GEO, Local SEOInsurance501-1K EmployeesN/ABirmingham, ALN/A- 4,600%+ increase in monthly organic traffic
- 671%+ increase in new organic keywords ranked
- 474% increase in AI Overview citations
Web Design, Web Development, UX RecommendationsInsurance10K+ EmployeesN/ANew York, NYN/A- 40% increase in car insurance leads (May 2026 vs May 2025)
- Highest website traffic since October 2025
- 30% above trailing 12-month monthly average traffic (first half of June 2026)
- #1 most-cited source in AI-powered insurance recommendations (May 2026)
AI, Platform ImplementationInsurance10K+ EmployeesN/ASanta Ana, CAN/A- 14 IT systems rationalized to one new platform
- 200+ pain points eliminated
- 1.2M working hours saved in offices
- 90% fewer employees lost to workload attrition
- 45% of workload offloaded from offices to new tooling
TV Advertising, Social Media Ads, Audio AdvertisingInsurance5K-10K EmployeesN/ADearborn, MIN/A- +24% More Quotes
- +11% Point Lift in Consideration
- +17 Point Lift in Purchase Intent
Programmatic Advertising, Media Mix Modeling, CROInsurance10K+ EmployeesN/ANew York, NYN/A- +7% increase in brand awareness
- +10% increase in qualified leads
- -15% cost per lead
Social Media Ads, CROInsurance1-10 EmployeesN/ANorcross, GAN/A- 11% Decrease in CPA
- 44% Increase in CTR
- 57% Increase in Conversions
Content Marketing, Email Marketing, Influencer Marketing, SEO, Social Media AdsInsurance51-200 EmployeesN/ARoslyn, NYN/A- +22% Organic Users
- +576% Paid Users
- +11% Direct Users
- +434% Conversion Rate
- +498% Conversions
Content Marketing, Social Media AdsInsuranceN/AN/ADurham, United KingdomN/A- 90,000+ LinkedIn reach and 1,900+ engagements
- 131,000+ paid social views and impressions
- 149 new LinkedIn page followers (2020 to June 2021)
Content Marketing, SEOInsuranceN/AN/ABorehamwood, United KingdomN/A- 61 pieces of coverage secured
- 35 links earned
- 2.47m estimated views
SEO, PPCInsuranceN/AN/AEwenny, United KingdomN/A- Three-fold increase in site visibility for 70 key terms in 6 months
- +183% year-on-year monthly traffic within 3 months
- +187% new users per month
Local SEO, SEOInsuranceN/AN/AHuntington Beach, CAN/A- +300% qualified leads
- +450% organic traffic
- 0 to 11 keywords in Google's Local 3-Pack (June 2019 to May 2026)
Content Marketing, BrandingInsuranceN/AN/AMinneapolis, MNN/A- Expanded into 3 markets over 12 months
- 13,650 magazines distributed in 2017
- 5 local influencers activated for the first edition
Web Design, SEO, BrandingInsuranceN/AN/AThe Woodlands, TXN/A- 100% More Users
- 80% More Sessions
- 85% More Returning Users
Email Marketing, Web DevelopmentInsurance10K+ EmployeesN/ANew York, NYN/A- Integrated email nurture system with microsites per partner nonprofit
- Warm lead pipeline from special-needs webinar series
Web Design, Content MarketingInsuranceN/AN/AN/AN/A- Custom WordPress site delivered in 9-12 months
- New positioning as a boutique insurance and advisory firm
- Yext listings set up for local SEO
PPC, Lead GenerationInsuranceN/AN/AN/AN/A- $453K gross profit in H2, up 40% from $322K
- 135% gross profit growth, August to September
- 5-7 new creatives tested every week
Web Design, Web DevelopmentInsuranceN/AN/AN/AN/A- Sitefinity upgrade
- UX improvements
- Responsive design
Content Marketing, SEOInsuranceN/AN/AN/AN/A- 331 total media pickups (industry avg. 201)
- 251 unique referring domains
- 867 net new ranked keywords
- 500+ monthly site visitors
Find the best Digital Marketing agencies in your industry
- Agriculture
- Automotive
- B2B
- Bank
- Beauty
- Construction
- Consulting
- Consumer Electronics
- Consumer Goods
- Cyber Security
- Dental
- Ecommerce
- Education
- Energy
- Entertainment
- Event Services
- Fashion
- Finance
- Fintech
- Fitness
- Food & Beverage
- Footwear
- Furniture
- Government
- Healthcare
- Home & Garden
- Home Services
- Hospitality
- Industrial
- Insurance
- Jewelry
- Landscaping
- Law Firm
- Logistics
- Manufacturing
- Marketing
- Medical Device
- Mental Health
- Moving
- MSP
- Museum & Cultural
- Non Profit
- Professional Services
- Real Estate
- Restaurant
- Retail
- SaaS
- Senior Care
- Software Development
- Sporting Goods
- Supplements
- Technology
- Telecom
- Transportation
- Travel
- University
- Wellness
Find the best Digital Marketing agencies in your country
Find the best Digital Marketing agencies in your state or region
Find the best Digital Marketing agencies in your city
- Atlanta, GA
- Austin, TX
- Boston, MA
- Chicago, IL
- Dallas, TX
- Denver, CO
- Hartford, CT
- Houston, TX
- London, United Kingdom
- Los Angeles, CA
- Miami, FL
- New Orleans, LA
- New York, NY
- Orlando, FL
- Philadelphia, PA
- Phoenix, AZ
- Salt Lake City, UT
- San Diego, CA
- San Francisco, CA
- Seattle, WA
- Tampa, FL
- Toronto, Canada
- Vancouver, Canada
- Washington, DC
Find the best Digital Marketing agencies for your business size