OpenServed

Best Insurance Content Marketing Agencies (2026) – Ranked by Case Studies

Previsible | The AI Discovery AgencyVisit Website →
Squaremouth Client-verified
GEO, SEO, Content Marketing
Insurance
11-50 Employees
N/A
St. Petersburg, FL
N/A
  • 270% more revenue from ChatGPT in 6 months
  • Search traffic up 78% while competitors lost 34.5% to AI Overviews
BraftonVisit Website →
FFVA Mutual
Content Marketing, SEO
Insurance
51-200 Employees
N/A
Maitland, FL
N/A
  • 3x total organic keyword rankings on blog in 2020
  • 26 new referring domains in 2020
  • 14% increase in blog sessions in 6 months
  • 9% increase in new users in 6 months
Ameritas
PPC, Content Marketing
Insurance
1K-5K Employees
N/A
Lincoln, NE
N/A
  • 132% increase in impressions
  • 161% increase in click-through rate
  • 289% increase in conversion rate
Stone Claims Group
Content Marketing, PPC, Email Marketing
Insurance
11-50 Employees
N/A
St. Petersburg, FL
N/A
  • 59 blog posts produced
  • 4850% increase in referring domains
  • 5x increase in organic traffic
Siege MediaVisit Website →
Embroker
Content Marketing, Link Building
Insurance
51-200 Employees
N/A
San Francisco, CA
N/A
  • Page One Ranking for "Startup Insurance"
  • 24,000% Increase in Organic Traffic to the Blog
  • 460% Increase in Links
The Zebra
Content Marketing, Link Building
Insurance
201-500 Employees
N/A
Austin, TX
N/A
  • 1,580+ Links Earned to Resources
  • $7.7M+ Increase in Traffic Value
  • 354% Increase in Organic Traffic
Choice Mutual
Content Marketing, SEO, Web Design
Insurance
1-10 Employees
N/A
Reno, NV
N/A
  • $123K Average Monthly Organic Traffic Value
  • 544 Links Earned to Date
  • 60% Increase in Monthly Organic Traffic
Adams & KnightVisit Website →
Travelers (Sara Under Siege)
Email Marketing, Content Marketing
Insurance
10K+ Employees
N/A
New York, NY
N/A
  • 74% likely to open another email
  • 67% more likely to quote Travelers auto policies
  • 66% said it changed how they think about Travelers
  • Six-episode animated email series
Travelers (Quantum Auto 2.0 Launch)
Email Marketing, Content Marketing
Insurance
10K+ Employees
N/A
New York, NY
N/A
  • Visits to the agent portal +620%
  • Email open rates above 50%
  • ~9 million consumer impressions through agents
Defend Your Income (Disability Insurance Campaign)
Content Marketing, PPC
Insurance
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
  • 33M+ print media impressions
  • 8M+ radio impressions
  • 65K+ visits to the website
  • 15+ trade press placements
PortentVisit Website →
Choice Mutual
Link Building, Content Marketing
Insurance
11-50 Employees
N/A
Reno, NV
N/A
  • 159% Increase in YoY Referral Traffic
  • 104% Increase in YoY Organic Traffic
  • 118 Earned Backlinks
DirectiveVisit Website →
healthinsurance.org
Content Marketing
Insurance
51-200 Employees
N/A
St. Louis Park, MN
N/A
  • 84% increase in Health Insurance Quotes
  • 46% increase in Organic Conversion Rates
  • 20,200 new Organic Users YoY
Lounge LizardVisit Website →
Physicians’ Reciprocal Insurers Marketing
Content Marketing, Email Marketing, Influencer Marketing, SEO, Social Media Ads
Insurance
51-200 Employees
N/A
Roslyn, NY
N/A
  • +22% Organic Users
  • +576% Paid Users
  • +11% Direct Users
  • +434% Conversion Rate
  • +498% Conversions
Harvey & HugoVisit Website →
Park Commercial
Content Marketing, Social Media Ads
Insurance
N/A
N/A
Durham, United Kingdom
N/A
  • 90,000+ LinkedIn reach and 1,900+ engagements
  • 131,000+ paid social views and impressions
  • 149 new LinkedIn page followers (2020 to June 2021)
Reflect DigitalVisit Website →
Everypaw
Content Marketing, SEO
Insurance
N/A
N/A
Borehamwood, United Kingdom
N/A
  • 61 pieces of coverage secured
  • 35 links earned
  • 2.47m estimated views
Communications Strategy Group (CSG®)Visit Website →
Bright Health
Content Marketing, Branding
Insurance
N/A
N/A
Minneapolis, MN
N/A
  • Expanded into 3 markets over 12 months
  • 13,650 magazines distributed in 2017
  • 5 local influencers activated for the first edition
Vendilli Digital GroupVisit Website →
Double E Insurance and Financial Services
Web Design, Content Marketing
Insurance
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
  • Custom WordPress site delivered in 9-12 months
  • New positioning as a boutique insurance and advisory firm
  • Yext listings set up for local SEO
Avalaunch MediaVisit Website →
Take Command
Content Marketing, SEO
Insurance
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
  • 331 total media pickups (industry avg. 201)
  • 251 unique referring domains
  • 867 net new ranked keywords
  • 500+ monthly site visitors
Origin FilmsVisit Website →
Fairfax/Northbridge
Content Marketing
Insurance
N/A
N/A
Toronto, Canada
N/A
  • Strategic executive interview series for recruitment and thought leadership
  • Brand video plus a library of long-form and short-form content
VIP MarketingVisit Website →
North American Senior Benefits
Content Marketing
Insurance
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
  • 10 agent videos produced in a three-day shoot