Best Insurance SEO Agencies (2026) – Ranked by Case Studies

1GS Digital Agency Visit Website →

First Family Insurance Client-verified

Social Media Ads, PPC, SEO

Insurance

11-50 Employees

N/A

Coral Springs, FL

N/A

1,000+ leads per month after a year, at a 30% landing page conversion rate
80% contact rate
Average cost per lead of $12, down from $26 in the first months

Phil Klein Insurance Group

Lead Generation, SEO, Email Marketing

Insurance

11-50 Employees

N/A

West Bloomfield, MI

N/A

1,400+ prospects generated in 60 days
Ranking for 177 keywords, up 132 in 60 days
347 LinkedIn conversations started in under 60 days

KBI Benefits

Lead Generation, PPC, SEO

Insurance

11-50 Employees

N/A

Los Altos, CA

N/A

31 B2B leads and 28 meetings in under 60 days
PPC landing pages converted 5.36% of visitors at about $138 per conversion

VOGLIO Digital Marketing Visit Website →

Fetch Pet Insurance Client-verified

PPC, Social Media Ads, SEO

Insurance

201-500 Employees

N/A

New York, NY

N/A

56% increase in new policy sales
400% increase in paid social sales
42% decrease in cost per sale
64% decrease in cost per sale for non-brand paid search

Bop Design Visit Website →

Perr&Knight Client-verified

Web Design, Web Development, SEO

Insurance

51-200 Employees

N/A

Boca Raton, FL

N/A

168% increase in contact form submissions
193% increase in consultation requests on the website
84% Growth in organic search traffic
125% increase in sessions
150% increase in rise in direct traffic

Forward Digital Consultancy Visit Website →

UniTrust Insurance Brokers Client-verified

SEO, PPC, Web Design

Insurance

51-200 Employees

N/A

Dubai, United Arab Emirates

N/A

400% lead generation
500K+ brand reach
Top 5 search rankings

Previsible | The AI Discovery Agency Visit Website →

Squaremouth Client-verified

GEO, SEO, Content Marketing

Insurance

11-50 Employees

N/A

St. Petersburg, FL

N/A

270% more revenue from ChatGPT in 6 months
Search traffic up 78% while competitors lost 34.5% to AI Overviews

Brafton Visit Website →

FFVA Mutual

Content Marketing, SEO

Insurance

51-200 Employees

N/A

Maitland, FL

N/A

3x total organic keyword rankings on blog in 2020
26 new referring domains in 2020
14% increase in blog sessions in 6 months
9% increase in new users in 6 months

Marsh McLennan Agency

Link Building, SEO, Content Marketing

Insurance

10K+ Employees

N/A

White Plains, NY

N/A

22 new backlinks acquired in one month
4500 backlinks acquired in one month
200 new referring domains in one month

CMR & Associates

Web Design, Web Development, SEO

Insurance

1-10 Employees

N/A

New York, NY

N/A

Users can find information in 7 clicks vs the 10-click goal

Primal Visit Website →

British Life Insurance

SEO

Insurance

N/A

39x Organic CNV Increase
6x Search Visibility Increase
4.4x Organic Traffic Increase

Asset Accumulation Insurance

SEO

Insurance

N/A

Top 3 Keywords Ranked
82% Impression Increase
55% Click Increase

Ink Digital Visit Website →

Devitt Insurance

SEO

Insurance

51-200 Employees

N/A

Romford, United Kingdom

N/A

58 new keywords in the top 3 positions
292 new keywords in the top 10 positions
First-page positions for keywords with 27,000+ monthly searches

SEO Brand Visit Website →

Infinity Insurance Agency

SEO, GEO, Local SEO

Insurance

501-1K Employees

N/A

Birmingham, AL

N/A

4,600%+ increase in monthly organic traffic
671%+ increase in new organic keywords ranked
474% increase in AI Overview citations

Siege Media Visit Website →

Choice Mutual

Content Marketing, SEO, Web Design

Insurance

1-10 Employees

N/A

Reno, NV

N/A

$123K Average Monthly Organic Traffic Value
544 Links Earned to Date
60% Increase in Monthly Organic Traffic

Lounge Lizard Visit Website →

Physicians’ Reciprocal Insurers Marketing

Content Marketing, Email Marketing, Influencer Marketing, SEO, Social Media Ads

Insurance

51-200 Employees

N/A

Roslyn, NY

N/A

+22% Organic Users
+576% Paid Users
+11% Direct Users
+434% Conversion Rate
+498% Conversions

Reflect Digital Visit Website →

Everypaw

Content Marketing, SEO

Insurance

N/A

Borehamwood, United Kingdom

N/A

61 pieces of coverage secured
35 links earned
2.47m estimated views

Innovation Visual Visit Website →

PedalCover

SEO, PPC

Insurance

N/A

Ewenny, United Kingdom

N/A

Three-fold increase in site visibility for 70 key terms in 6 months
+183% year-on-year monthly traffic within 3 months
+187% new users per month

BCC Interactive Visit Website →

SoCal Insurance & Financial

Local SEO, SEO

Insurance

N/A

Huntington Beach, CA

N/A

+300% qualified leads
+450% organic traffic
0 to 11 keywords in Google's Local 3-Pack (June 2019 to May 2026)

ITVibes, Inc Visit Website →

Dickey Insurance Solutions

Web Design, SEO, Branding

Insurance

N/A

The Woodlands, TX

N/A

100% More Users
80% More Sessions
85% More Returning Users

Impressive Digital Agency Visit Website →

iSelect

SEO

Insurance

N/A

Melbourne, Australia

N/A

#1 for "health insurance" (38,000 searches a month)
#1 for "private health insurance" (30,000 searches a month)
Page 1 for "compare car insurance" (21,000 searches a month)

Straight North Visit Website →

Figo

SEO

Insurance

51-200 Employees

N/A

Chicago, IL

N/A

2,097% Increase in traffic

Agency EA

SEO

Insurance

N/A

2,400% Increase in conversions

Avalaunch Media Visit Website →

Take Command

Content Marketing, SEO

Insurance

N/A

331 total media pickups (industry avg. 201)
251 unique referring domains
867 net new ranked keywords
500+ monthly site visitors

Search Berg Visit Website →

Delaughter Bail Bonds

SEO

Insurance

N/A

Fort Wayne, IN

N/A

736% increase in organic traffic over 2 years
1,000% increase in organic keyword rankings

ICS Creative Agency Visit Website →

GoToInsure

PPC, SEO, Web Development

Insurance

51-200 Employees

N/A

14% conversion rate

Opace Digital Agency Visit Website →

Classic Line Insurance

SEO, Web Development

Insurance

N/A

Page 1 Google ranking for "Classic Car Insurance"

Find the best SEO agencies in your industry